Evaluating School Districts Before Moving
Home Approach
Key Takeaways
A comprehensive guide to evaluating and comparing school districts. Why first-time homebuyers should consider school district quality before making a home-buying decision.
A Comprehensive Guide to Evaluating & Comparing School Districts
Moving to a new location can be an exciting yet daunting task — especially when you have children and their education to consider.
Surprisingly, many first-time homebuyers don't realize that the quality of a school district and the efficiency with which it utilizes its resources affects homeowners of all ages and situations, regardless of their family composition.
Why school district quality matters for first-time homebuyers
When school districts boast a superior reputation, they draw in families who seek a quality education for their children. Prudent first-time homebuyers also know that a school district with a long track of excellence will lead to an increase in their home value over time.
The most important factor to consider
In many ways, consideration of the local school district is one of the most important factors to consider when making what is often the largest one-time financial investment a person or family makes.
It is important to balance factors with the tax rate of your potential home or neighborhood. While you can pay mortgage payments down over time, local school district taxes are likely to rise over time.
The 3 R's: School Rankings, Ratings, and Resources
Websites like Niche.com use multiple factors to rank and rate schools such as SAT/ACT test scores, parent surveys, teacher salary, expenses per student, cultural diversity statistics, and availability of extracurricular clubs or sports.
1. What you actually take home
What actually lands in your account each month, after taxes and deductions.
2. The full cost of the house
Principal, interest, taxes, and insurance for the home you're considering.
About 1% of home value per year, divided by 12.
Electric, gas, water, sewer, trash, internet.
Leave at 0 if there is no association.
3. The life a lender can’t see
Underwriting ignores this entirely.
The contribution you refuse to stop making.
Groceries, gas, insurance, subscriptions, eating out.
Bank qualification vs. your real monthly housing number
Bank qualification
$3,120
Illustrative 36% debt ratio applied to estimated gross income. Ignores maintenance, childcare, savings, and everyday spending.
Your real monthly housing number
$1,625
25% of net income, capped by what’s left after the commitments you entered.
A lender would approve about $1,495 more per month than your budget supports. That gap is the house-poor zone.
Your summary
Over your ceiling
A lender may still approve this. Your budget is telling you something different.
- All-in housing cost
- $2,793
- Comfort target (25% of net)
- $1,625
- Safety ceiling (30% of net)
- $1,950
- Left for housing after your commitments
- $4,400
Factors to consider when evaluating a school district
1. Student performance
Far and away the number one factor used to rate schools is some measure of student performance. Nationwide standardized tests such as the SATs and ACTs provide a measure of student achievement.
2. College and career readiness
College readiness is typically measured by analyzing advanced placement courses available to students, participation rates, and outcomes on AP tests.
3. Teacher and leadership quality
Teacher quality is a complex and multifaceted concept. Methods include classroom observations, student performance data, professional development engagement, and parent surveys.
4. Facilities and resources
School taxes go largely towards a school's budget. Adequate and well-maintained facilities create a safe and conducive learning environment for students.
5. Equity and Cultural Diversity Factors
Schools that prioritize equity provide targeted support to students who may face challenges due to socioeconomic status, language barriers, or disabilities.
6. Community involvement and safety
Visit schools and surrounding areas, attend a school board meeting, and research local safety data when evaluating school districts.
Disclaimer: The content provided on this website is offered for educational purposes only. Visitors are advised to consult with qualified experts before making any financial decisions.
Try these free tools
All toolsHome Approach Straight To Your Inbox
Get the insights you need to achieve your homeownership goals!
